The Dangers of Partisan Expert Evidence: Lessons from Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust

The judgment in Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust, dated December 2025, provides an important reminder of the need for independence and objectivity in clinical negligence litigation.
The danger of personal preference
A central issue was the evidence of the claimant’s expert. Rather than fully considering the range of reasonable options available in the circumstances, the expert appears to have placed significant emphasis on what they personally would have done. Their preferred approach was treated as though it represented the only correct course.
That approach creates a serious risk. Expert evidence must not become an exercise in defending one side’s case. The expert’s role is to assist the court by providing an impartial opinion based on accepted practice, the circumstances existing at the relevant time, and the range of reasonable clinical judgments available.
The court was not persuaded by the claimant’s expert’s approach and preferred the evidence of the defendant’s expert. This illustrates the dangers of evidence that appears overly supportive or partisan. Even where an expert genuinely believes that a different course would have been preferable, that is not necessarily enough to establish negligence.
The right question for an expert
The correct question is not simply: ‘What would I have done?’ It is: ‘Was the treatment provided outside the range of reasonable professional practice in the circumstances?’
That distinction is crucial. Clinical negligence cases often involve difficult decisions, incomplete information and more than one defensible option. Retrospective criticism must therefore be approached with caution.
A lesson for expert witnesses
The case is a useful warning to experts and those instructing them. A persuasive report should acknowledge reasonable alternatives, engage fairly with the opposing evidence and distinguish between personal preference and professional breach.
Partisan evidence may appear helpful in the short term, but it can ultimately damage the credibility of the entire case.
This article is a general discussion of the judgment and is not legal advice. The judgment and expert evidence should be considered in full before relying on any particular interpretation.



Comments